Front Page
South Africa
Politics  
Crime & Courts  
Education
Health  
Environment  
Tourism  
Transport  
Development  
Lottery
Finance & Labour  
General  
Africa
World
Science & Tech
A Step Beyond
IOL Top Stories  
Picture Gallery  
Sport
Business Report
Personal Finance
Chill Out
Travel
Weather
Motoring
Careers
Classifieds
Search Wheels
Search Jobs
Search Property
News I Can Use
Letters/ Opinions
Site Feedback
Cellphone Fun
Games
Horoscopes
About IOL
Newspapers
Special Features
Iraq Invasion
Cricket World Cup
Middle East Crisis
Zimbabwe
Focus on Aids
More Features
   
 




 
  Clean up or pay up, state tells Thor

March 13 2003 at 08:00AM
Mercury new

By Tony Carnie

The government flexed its new anti-pollution muscles on Wednesday when it ordered Thor Chemicals to start cleaning up thousands of tons of toxic mercury waste - or be saddled with a R60-million government clean-up bill.

The order, made under the "polluter-pays" provisions of the National Environmental Management Act of 1998, directs the owners of the chemical plant in Cato Ridge, KwaZulu-Natal, to begin a major clean-up operation of an estimated 8 000 tons of toxic sludge stored in warehouses and waste ponds.

It is the first time the government has invoked the provisions of the act, which imposes a strict duty on industries to avoid pollution or to bear the costs of cleaning up their mess.

Carrying a thick sheaf of documents, deputy environment minister Rejoice Mabudafhasi drove to Cato Ridge on Wednesday to make a "courtesy call" on factory officials, before returning to Durban to hand over the clean-up directive to a legal representative of Guernica Chemicals (a new name for Thor's chemical operations in South Africa).

'People come first, because no country can survive without people'
Durban attorney Roy Monk, who is acting for Guernica Chemicals, said he had not studied the lengthy directive yet but said the company had been given 30 days to prepare a formal response.

Mabudafhasi, who addressed media and members of the surrounding Inchanga community at the factory gates, said all companies investing in this country had to observe the law and protect the health of workers and neighbours.

"We are saying that people come first, because no country can survive without people," she said.

The government had estimated it would cost about R60-million to clean up the legacy of actual and potential ground and water pollution at the factory and outside its gates.

Asked to comment on whether Thor/Guernica could afford to foot the bill following reports of a major restructuring and reshuffling of assets, Mabudafhasi said: "We are determined to fight this war... and we will certainly want our money back."

The company has already agreed to pay almost R12-million in out-of-court settlements
She would also contact British environment minister Michael Meacher to urge him to intervene and provide assistance. Thor/Guernica's parent company is based in Britain, where it has also faced a series of civil damages claims for allegedly killing or poisoning workers in Kwa-Zulu Natal.

The company has already agreed to pay almost R12-million in out-of-court settlements after damages claims brought by more than 30 former Thor workers and their relatives.

Buti Mathebula, government director of chemicals and hazardous waste management, said there was at least 3 500 tons of mercury sludge which would have to be transferred into newer storage vessels.

However, the most immediate concern was to prevent mercury leaking into the soil and groundwater around the factory. Several thousand tons of sludge was sitting in leachate dams and there was evidence that some of this had started to leak out.

Mathebula did not spell out the eventual fate of imported toxic wastes, which Thor had hoped to burn in an incinerator.

Guernica attorney Monk said his clients had been waiting for several years for a formal government response on how to deal with the stored mercury waste.

A state-appointed commission had recommended incineration as the best way of dealing with the stockpile, but this option "did not seem to find favour" with the government.

He would not comment on his client's ability to pay the clean-up bill, but said a more detailed statement would be issued in a fortnight.

  • Several environmental organisations, which were instrumental in putting pressure on the government to deal with Thor's chemical legacy, have welcomed the move.

    Bobby Peek, of the environmental watchdog group GroundWork, said despite legal claims in the British courts, the South African government and judiciary had failed until Wednesday to hold Thor accountable.

    "Hopefully this action signals a new willingness within government to hold polluting companies accountable for the damage they are causing to human lives and the environment in South Africa," he said.

    Kenny Bruno of EarthRights International, United States, who campaigned to stop mercury exports from the US to Thor in the early 1990s, said: "This was a classic case of transnational corporate malfeasance - and if ever there was a case that cried out for government to step in and require action, this is it.

    "The clean-up will protect health, protect the environment, and send a message that companies must abide by legal standards and the standards of basic decency," he said.

    Jim Puckett of the US-based Basel Action Network, an international toxic-trade watchdog, said South African soil should never be used as a dumping ground for the poisons that foreign industrialists wanted to get rid of.

    Earthlife Africa's Bryan Ashe also commended minister Mabudafhasi but said provincial officials of the water affairs department should have taken action years ago.

    • This article was originally published on page 1 of The Mercury on 13 March 2003

  •  
    Read more about this in our special feature - Click here

    To receive news headlines via SMS click here.
    (Available only to Vodacom contract subscribers)


       



       


     
     
     
     
    Have some fun with your phone! Download your favourite Easter and F1 group graphics and picture messages.

    Subscribe to IOL's Newsletter  Front Page  South Africa  Africa  World  Science & Tech  A Step Beyond  Picture Gallery  Sport  Chill Out  Travel  Weather  Motoring  Career Guides  News I Can Use  IOL Top Stories  Letters & Opinions  Site Feedback  Search IOL Newspapers 

     
    IOL's Frequently Asked Questions
    Click here to login to IOLMail





    For all your Commerical Property Needs











     
    Back

     
     
    ©2003. All rights strictly reserved.
    Independent Online is a wholly owned subsidiary of Independent News & Media. Reliance on the information this site contains is at your own risk.
    Please read the user agreement and privacy policy. Write to feedback@iol.co.za
    Tel: +27 21 481 6200, Fax: +27 21 481 6292
    Click here for more information on IOL