By Yvette Greslé.
Photo credit: Sofie Knijff
Despite the sincerity of the artists who have brazenly maintained a relationship in their work with the black body, there is a certain over-determination that accompanies their gestures. They seem to neglect the fact that the black form is as much a grotesque bearer of traumatised experiences as it is the abject vessel of race as a point of differentiation. More than alerting us to how the stereotype fixes its objects of desire in that freeze-frame of realism, as prior knowledge, the work of these artists exacerbates the stereotype by replaying it, perhaps unconsciously, as if it had always been factual.
(Okwui Enwezor). [1]
I have always suspected that most South Africans do not understand what racism is. There is a disconnect between what happened in the past and our experience of today. I feel that we wiped the memory of racism’s definition as according to our experience.
(Simphiwe Dana). [2]
Brett Bailey’s performance-installation Exhibit B casts black performers in roles that require them to perform his theatrical fantasy. Interviewed for the Agenda Magazine blog, in 2012, on the occasion of a prior staging of Exhibit B in Brussels, Bailey says: ‘I’m bringing five performers with me. The others are Africans living in Brussels. Some of them are asylum-seekers. And yes, I do put them in glass displays and cabinets and things like that. One by one, the spectators go in and do a tour’. This grotesque exploitation of asylum-seekers, and its associated reiteration of historical racial abuse, is facilitated by Bailey’s company ‘Third World Bunfight‘. In a BBC video, which includes rehearsal footage, the mannered, and controlled nature of Bailey’s approach to performance is evident. He tells us: ‘I am a performance-maker. I come from South Africa. I am interested in beauty and the objectification of people. Turning them into beautiful objects. I am very interested in the seductive quality of beauty. Then also in what lies behind that beauty and the horror that is there’. Exhibit B, is in Bailey’s words:
Somewhere between performance, theater and an art exhibition. I read a book called Africans on Stage which gave me insight into the phenomenon of human zoos and that was the catalyst for making this work. What was behind human zoos was the representation of the Other in a particular way, to de-humanise and objectify them. I take colonial history. I take the atrocities that were committed under colonialism right from the 19th century all the way up until the liberation of the 1950s and 1960s. And then I look at the residues of racism. Or the racism that we are still living with today (BBC video).
Bailey does not pause to reflect on the meaning of this ‘we’ and his own complicity in histories of racism, which he re-inscribes in Exhibit B. An audition call-out to black performers for the forthcoming Barbican iteration of Exhibit B can be found here. This document is revealing both in what it says about Bailey’s complicity in racial type-casting, and the historical rendering of the bodies of black women: ‘Please note that two women will be required to perform topless’ and ‘A range of African and Caribbean men and women of various heights will be cast (including specifically 1 man and 1 woman who are no taller than 5.2 ft)’. [3] As Achille Mbembe puts it:
We should remind ourselves that, as a general rule, the experience of the Other, or the problem of the “I” of others and of human beings we perceive as foreign to us, has almost always posed virtually insurmountable difficulties to the Western philosophical and political tradition. Whether dealing with Africa or with other non-European worlds, this tradition long denied the existence of any “self” but its own. [4]
Visual strategies that offer a radical critique of historical practices, of the problem of the ‘I’ and of the ‘Other’ (and the relevance of this to the history of white supremacy in South Africa) appear to be absent from Bailey’s vocabulary. On a petition, organised by journalist and activist Sara Myers, on Change.Org, Myers writes to black publics: ‘I’ve been sent a link to a preview of the Exhibit I want you to watch it not as spectator or as an observer. I want you to watch it through the eyes of your DNA. I want you to experience the atrocities our ancestors experienced through the hands of white supremacy. Though it’s a part of our history it’s by no means the whole of our story.’ This statement tells of the relationship between historical racial abuse, the relationship to trauma, and the imposition of voices that speak from a position of whiteness and the power relations that this implies. It is this voice and this history that Bailey discounts. The writer and scholar John Edwin Mason tweeted @johnedwinmason, on the 12 August: ‘Well, at the very least, he seems incapable of asking the deepest questions – those that involve himself’. Mason notes in discussions, on Twitter, Bailey’s ‘willingness to ask his actors to reenact their ancestor’s humiliation’.
Circulating on Twitter are references to colonial exhibitions in the work of Coco Fusco and Guillermo Gómez-Peña. An article published in BOMB magazine contextualises this: ‘In March 1992, performance artist and MacArthur Fellow, Guillermo Gómez-Peña and writer/artist Coco Fusco locked themselves in a cage. Presenting themselves as aboriginal inhabitants of an island off the gulf of Mexico that was overlooked by Columbus, their spectacle provided a thorn in the side of postcolonial angst’. [5] But here the artists, who themselves embody histories and lived experiences of race, deploy strategies that exist in a considered, self-reflexive relation to the discourse on race. Both artists are aware of the critical capacities of performance: they deployed strategies such as parody and the actual bodily and tactile blurring of the space between audience and performer. Most importantly, they placed themselves in the cage. Artist and Editor Nathalie Dubruel (@mudlarky) circulated, on Twitter, the video clip (‘The Couple in a Cage’) showing aspects of this performance (which appears on YouTube).
Exhibit B has sparked controversy across the cities in which it has recently appeared: Berlin, and Edinburgh, and is due to arrive in London at The Barbican in September. The Barbican will also be staging Bailey’s Macbeth. Accounts of Exhibit B and critical responses in the United Kingdom have appeared in The Guardian, WOW 24/7, The Telegraph, The Financial Times, The Voice, and Ligali. Critiques have also appeared on independent platforms such as Minor Literature[s] and blogposts, notably that of artist and performer Selina Thompson. Sadiah Quereshi, a lecturer in Modern History at the University of Birmingham has written an historical account of European practices of human exhibits from the 15th Century to the 19th Century. She includes archival research that lends ambiguity to European/African relations: ’In 1899, news broke that Kitty Jewell had become engaged to the star of the Savage South Africa exhibition at Earl’s court, Prince Peter Kushana Lobengula’. [6] Quereshi’s response to Exhibit B is published in The Conversation.
Bailey claims that his work has a political and an ethical purpose: he speaks of his relationship to apartheid South Africa. But responses posted on social media, including Twitter, over the past two weeks, speak to what is so unethical about Bailey’s work: ‘If your intent is to subvert the long history of human zoos, why are you still using Black bodies? Why not address the white gaze? (Mikki Kendall @Karnythia). In response to the criticism, and indeed anger, mounting in London, the Barbican issued a statement (which they tweeted to me personally on 22 August 2014). This counter-argument, or rather Public Relations script, was written (we are told) by Toni Racklin (Head of Theatre); Jan Ryan (Director UK Arts International and Brett Bailey (Director of Exhibit B) and is an example of assumption-making and condescension. It is inappropriate as a form of delivery to audiences who are visually literate; it is inappropriate to audiences who have lived and embodied experiences of racial abuse and discrimination. It is a document that enlists quotes from actual performers, in positive vein, although I personally, interested in what is unsaid, am sceptical. John O’ Mahony’s piece for The Guardian suggests that the relationship between work and performer is not that straightforward: ‘The only problem is that the young black performers, cast locally at every stop along the tour, aren’t quite getting it. “How do you know we are not entertaining people the same way the human zoos did?” asks one. “How can you be sure that it’s not just white people curious about seeing black people?” adds another.’ [7] Barbican responses to criticism speaks to the convergence of Public Relations, Power, Race and cultural institutions in the United Kingdom. Bailey appears unaware of one of the most critical questions of post-apartheid South Africa: Who speaks, for whom and how? His own complicity in this history is absent from his work. In response to the outrage and criticism, in London he replies:
Exhibit B is not a piece about black histories made for white audiences. It is a piece about humanity; about a system of dehumanisation that affects everybody in society, regardless of skin colour, ethnic or cultural background, that scours the humanity from the ‘looker’ and the ‘looked at’. A system that emphasises difference rather than similarity. A system that gave birth to the hegemonic regime of separation in which I grew up, and which continues to haunt the people of my country. The kind of systems we need to guard against (Barbican statement).
As I write this in August 2014 I wonder how those affected by, for example, the events of Marikana in South Africa would feel about this version of humanity and about Bailey’s assumption of a ‘we’. In August a controversy around white South African students enacting Blackface and caricatured dress-ups of the bodies of black South Africans erupted on Twitter and Facebook. The South African writer and intellectual T.O Molefe responded with a Storify critique. It is as though Bailey imagines himself an auteur offering audiences (upon whom he projects his many assumptions) a lesson in racist abuses. But his lesson is crudely wielded. Exhibit B – the title actually says it all – is a stage set of inanimate objects including the silent black performers. The beautiful and evocative music that accompanies the installation functions manipulatively: It lulled me into an emotional space within which I almost forgot what it was I was looking at. Bailey’s performers must not only embody traumatic histories choreographed by a white South African man but also offer up their private narratives and experiences of racism for the scrutiny of white audiences. Racklin tells us: The final room of the installation contains some of the [testimonies of the performers] reflecting on both their involvement in the piece and providing their personal experiences of racism and prejudice they’ve experienced in their own lives’ (Barbican statement). In a crude appropriation of ‘the gaze’ we are told by Racklin: ‘Visitors to the performance are forced to confront the reality of this dehumanizing treatment with the performers directly meeting the eye of audience members’. But who decides what it is this gaze means? If an analysis grounded in racial abuse and trauma were to be applied to Bailey’s tableaus what would emerge would be very unsettling indeed. Furthermore, The Barbican is charging £20 to view the spectacle: the historical relationship between racial violations and profit is re-visited here, unambiguously.
There are contradictions present in Bailey’s response to criticism. In the audition call-out, cited earlier, he states: ‘Since 2001, as a white South African performance maker, I have travelled regularly to Europe with casts of black performers to present works at festivals for the diversion of (mainly) white audiences’. In the Barbican Statement, we read: ’Exhibit B is not a piece about black histories made for white audiences’. He tells us too: “Nowhere do I term Exhibit B a ‘human zoo’”. And yet the term ‘human zoo’ is mobilised by Bailey on a number of occasions in discussions of the work. The BBC video is one example.
That Bailey is a South African classified white by the apartheid regime is of importance to the debates about this exhibition. His documented responses to the criticism (directed at him) speaks to some of the social and political attitudes that apartheid South Africa produced. Twenty years after the official transition into democracy and one Truth and Reconciliation Commission later we find ourselves in a social and political space within which past overlays the ever troublesome concerns of the present. This is a context where race is still visibly inscribed, not only in the major disconnections that prevail in social and political relations but also in the visible reminders of apartheid era urban planning. Events such as Marikana speak to the ambiguities that exist between apartheid/post-apartheid social and economic structures: South Africa’s brutal, historical relationship to capitalism (and its relationship to race-related abuses) is all-pervasive. There is not one South African, classified white by the apartheid administration, who can claim to be untouched by the regime’s deliberate and calculated project of white supremacy; its ideologies and systems of indoctrination. So systemic and insidious was its campaign to categorise and separate racial groupings and hierarchies that not even the most liberal or left-leaning white South African can claim not to have absorbed some form of racial prejudice (or not to have benefited in one form or another from the structural privileges which it engendered). I am not calling for a performance of guilt and self-flagellation but rather some humility, and careful, considered dialogue.
One of the most ubiquitous examples of the overlay between apartheid South Africa and the present is the belief (held by the privileged) in the absolute authority of one’s own voice. This voice is not to be challenged or questioned. The critic runs the risk of being condescended, shouted down, stonewalled, diminished or simply ignored. If the critic is perceived to hold little social, political or economic power there is only a void in which to protest. It appears that this is not only the preserve of the conditions that apartheid produced. In a disconcerting overlap of geographical-political conditions the Barbican’s response to the criticism wielded at Bailey’s Exhibit B is reminiscent of South Africa past and present. It opens up a space for thinking about cultural institutions in London and their relationship to histories of slavery, colonialism, and contemporary forms of racism. It is as though the Barbican, similarly to cultural institutions in South Africa, find it difficult to imagine multiple audiences shaped by more than one subjectivity. The Barbican has responded to criticism with a document that finds itself unable to communicate in a considered and human manner with the critiques that are currently being wielded at Exhibit B. This is one of the most distinctive markers of privileged whiteness: The absence of humility, of a self-reflexive, considered dialogue with subjects who have a direct, historical (and traumatic) relation to racist lineages, overt and insidious. And this from an institution located in a city that so deliberately stages the language of multicultural and cosmopolitan.
Endnotes
[1] Enwezor, O. ‘Reframing the Black Subject: Ideology and Fantasy in Contemporary South African Representation’. In Oguibe, O and Enwezor, E. (eds) Reading the Contemporary: African Art from Theory to the Market Place. London: Institute of International Visual Arts, 1999, pp. 376-399. See: http://www.iniva.org/library/archive/people/e/enwezor_okwui/reframing_the_black_subject_ideology_and_fantasy (Last accessed 24 August 2014).
[2] Dana, S. ‘Don’t wish the rainbow on Palestine’, Mail & Guardian, 15 August 2014. http://mg.co.za/article/2014-08-14-dont-wish-the-rainbow-on-palestine (last accessed 24 August 2014).
[3] See the work of South African scholars such as Pumla Dineo Gqola and Desiree Lewis for a discourse on gender and race. Refer too to the critical art practices of South African women artists notably Tracey Rose.
[4] Mbembe, A. On the Postcolony. Berkeley, Los Angeles, London: University of California Press, 2001, p.2.
[5] Johnson, A. ‘Artists in Conversation: Coco Fusco and Guillermo Gómez-Peña’. BOMB Magazine, Issue 4, Winter 1993, http://bombmagazine.org/article/1599/ (Last accessed 25 August 2014).
[6] Quereshi, S. ‘Exhibit B puts people on display for Edinburgh International Festival, The Conversation, 11 August 2014 http://theconversation.com/exhibit-b-puts-people-on-display-for-edinburgh-international-festival-30344 (Last accessed 25 August 2014).
[7] O’ Mahony, J. ‘Edinburgh’s most controversial show: Exhibit B, a human zoo’, The Guardian, Monday 11 August 2014, http://www.theguardian.com/stage/2014/aug/11/-sp-exhibit-b-human-zoo-edinburgh-festivals-most-controversial (Last accessed 25 August 2014).
Refer to an interview from a public discussion (transcribed by Nathanael Vlachos) that took place between Brett Bailey and Anton Krueger as part of a series called ‘Talking Arts’ at Thinkfest, at the 2012 National Arts Festival held in Grahamstown, South Africa.
See: Coombes, A. Reinventing Africa: Museums, Material Culture and Popular Imagination in Late Victorian and Edwardian England, United State: Yale University Press, 1997.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Yvette Greslé is an art historian, writer and blogger. She is currently completing her PhD, on South African video art, history and traumatic memory, at University College London. Yvette is a senior editor at Minor Literature[s]. Her art criticism has appeared in ‘this is tomorrow’, Apollo Magazine (blog), Photomonitor and Art South Africa amongst others. She is also a Research Associate at the University of Johannesburg. She tweets @yvettegresle.
First published in 3:AM Magazine: Wednesday, August 27th, 2014.
Hi, i read your blog from time to time and i own a similar one and i was just curious if you get a lot of spam remarks?
If so how do you reduce it, any plugin or anything you can recommend?
I get so much lately it’s driving me crazy so any assistance is very much appreciated.
For newest news you have to visit web and on the web I found
this website as a finest site for newest updates.
I am sure this post has touched all the internet users, its really
really nice paragraph on building up new web site.
If you want to take much from this article then you have to apply these
methods to your won web site.
Do you mind if I quote a few of your articles
as long as I provide credit and sources back to your weblog?
My blog site is in the very same niche as yours and my users would definitely benefit from some
of the information you present here. Please let me know if this ok with you.
Cheers!
I’m curious to find out what blog system you have been working with? I’m having some small security issues with my latest site and I’d like to find something more safeguarded. Do you have any suggestions?
Thanks a bunch for sharing this with all of us you actually know what you are talking about! Bookmarked. Kindly also visit my site =). We could have a link exchange agreement between us!
This is one awesome article.Thanks Again. Want more.
What’s up to all, how is everything, I think every one is getting more from this web site,
and your views are good in support of new users.
I’ve been surfing on-line more than three hours today, but I by no means found any interesting article like yours. It is pretty price enough for me. Personally, if all web owners and bloggers made just right content as you probably did, the net can be a lot more useful than ever before.
Does your site have a contact page? I’m having problems locating it but, I’d like to shoot you an e-mail. I’ve got some recommendations for your blog you might be interested in hearing. Either way, great blog and I look forward to seeing it improve over time.
Pretty section of content. I just stumbled upon your
weblog and in accession capital to assert that I get in fact enjoyed account your blog posts.
Any way I’ll be subscribing to your feeds and even I achievement you access consistently rapidly.
Aw, this was a actually good post. In notion I would like to put in writing like this moreover – taking time and actual effort to make a very good article… but what can I say… I procrastinate alot and by no means seem to get one thing accomplished.
Hi! I’m at work surfing around your blog from my new apple iphone! Just wanted to say I love reading your blog and look forward to all your posts! Carry on the superb work!
I read this piece of writing completely concerning the difference of hottest and previous technologies, it’s remarkable article.
My brother recommended I might like this blog. He was once entirely right.
This post actually made my day. You can not imagine simply how a lot time I had spent for this information! Thank
you!
Magnificent web site. A lot of helpful information here.
I’m sending it to several friends ans also sharing in delicious.
And of course, thank you on your effort!
My family always say that I am wasting my time here at
web, however I know I am getting knowledge all the time by reading such fastidious articles or
reviews.
Right away I am ready to do my breakfast, once having my breakfast
coming over again to read additional news.
Hi my family member! I wish to say that this post is awesome, great written and come with approximately all vital infos. I would like to look more posts like this .
I’m gone to say to my little brother, that he should also go to see this blog
on regular basis to get updated from most recent news.
I discovered your blog website on google and check a number of of your early posts. Continue to keep up the incredibly beneficial operate. I just additional up your RSS feed to my MSN News Reader. Searching for forward to reading more from you later on!
I think this is one of the most important info for me.
And i am glad reading your article. But wanna remark on some general things,
The website style is perfect, the articles is really nice : D.
Good job, cheers
Wonderful blog! I found it while browsing on Yahoo News.
Do you have any tips on how to get listed in Yahoo News?
I’ve been trying for a while but I never seem to get there!
Thanks
Excellent site you have here but I was wanting to know if you knew of
any forums that cover the same topics talked about in this article?
I’d really like to be a part of group where I can get opinions from other knowledgeable individuals that share the same interest.
If you have any suggestions, please let me know.
Thank you!
Unquestionably consider that which you said. Your favourite reason appeared to be at the internet the easiest thing to consider of. I say to you, I definitely get irked even as people consider concerns that they just do not know about. You managed to hit the nail upon the highest as neatly as outlined out the entire thing without having side-effects , people can take a signal. Will probably be again to get more. Thanks
Very good written article. It will be useful to everyone who utilizes it, as well as myself. Keep doing what you are doing – looking forward to more posts.
I read this paragraph fully on the topic of the resemblance
of hottest and earlier technologies, it’s awesome article.
I have read a few just right stuff here. Certainly worth bookmarking for revisiting. I surprise how much attempt you put to create the sort of fantastic informative web site.
Greetings from Florida! I’m bored to tears at work so I decided to browse your website on my iphone during lunch break. I love the knowledge you provide here and can’t wait to take a look when I get home. I’m shocked at how quick your blog loaded on my phone .. I’m not even using WIFI, just 3G .. Anyhow, fantastic site!
I’ve been exploring for a little for any high quality articles or weblog posts in this kind of space . Exploring in Yahoo I ultimately stumbled upon this website. Reading this information So i am glad to show that I have an incredibly excellent uncanny feeling I came upon exactly what I needed. I such a lot surely will make sure to don’t put out of your mind this site and provides it a glance regularly.
Pretty! This has been a really wonderful post.
Thanks for supplying these details.
I’ve been exploring for a little bit for any high quality articles or weblog posts
in this sort of space . Exploring in Yahoo I finally stumbled upon this
web site. Studying this information So i am
glad to convey that I’ve an incredibly just right uncanny feeling I came upon just what I needed.
I most indisputably will make certain to do not fail
to remember this web site and provides it a look regularly.
Very good written post. It will be beneficial to anybody who employess it, as well as myself. Keep doing what you are doing – for sure i will check out more posts.
It’s a pity you don’t have a donate button! I’d most certainly donate to this excellent blog! I guess for now i’ll settle for bookmarking and adding your RSS feed to my Google account. I look forward to new updates and will talk about this blog with my Facebook group. Chat soon!
It is appropriate time to make some plans for the future and it is time to be happy. I have read this post and if I could I desire to suggest you some interesting things or suggestions. Maybe you could write next articles referring to this article. I wish to read even more things about it!
I blog frequently and I genuinely appreciate your content.
This great article has truly peaked my interest. I’m going to book mark your blog and keep checking for new information about once per week.
I opted in for your Feed too.
I’ve been exploring for a little for any high
quality articles or blog posts in this kind of house . Exploring in Yahoo I at last stumbled upon this website.
Reading this info So i am satisfied to convey that I have a very good uncanny feeling I came upon just what
I needed. I so much surely will make sure to don?t forget this site and provides it a glance on a constant basis.
rmdxDc http://www.LnAJ7K8QSpkiStk3sLL0hQP6MO2wQ8gO.com
Wonderful goods from you, man. I’ve understand your stuff previous to and you are just extremely wonderful.
I really like what you’ve acquired here, certainly like what you’re saying and the way in which you
say it. You make it enjoyable and you still take
care of to keep it sensible. I cant wait to read
far more from you. This is really a tremendous website.
What’s up to all, it’s genuinely a pleasant for me to go to see this website,
it contains helpful Information.
This design is spectacular! You definitely know how to keep a reader amused.
Between your wit and your videos, I was almost moved to start my own blog (well, almost…HaHa!) Fantastic job.
I really loved what you had to say, and more than that, how you
presented it. Too cool!
Prix Du Levitra Au Maroc [url=http://cial1.xyz/brand-cialis-online.php]Brand Cialis Online[/url] Cialis Garantito Pyridium Increased Urination [url=http://buyprednis.xyz/cheap-deltasone-online.php]Cheap Deltasone Online[/url] Amoxicillin Dosing In Infants Cialis 10mg Rezeptfrei Bestellen [url=http://buykama.xyz/low-cost-kamagra-online.php]Low Cost Kamagra Online[/url] Propecia Cost Blog Amoxicillin Clav Drug [url=http://buyzol.xyz/zoloft-cheap.php]Zoloft Cheap[/url] Le Viagra Est Il Efficace Kamagra Zollprobleme [url=http://amox1.xyz/generic-amoxil-buy.php]Generic Amoxil Buy[/url] Ceftin And Keflex Where Can I Get Free Viagra Samples [url=http://propeus.xyz/propecia-ritalin.php]Propecia Ritalin[/url] Best Generic Cialis Site Viagra American Distrubution [url=http://buycheapusa.xyz/map.php]Priligy Buy Online Usa[/url] Buy Tamoxifen Citrate No Prescription Baclofen Pas Cher 10mg [url=http://zol1.xyz/purchase-zoloft.php]Purchase Zoloft[/url] Viagra En Allemand Where To Buy Kamagra Oral Jelly In Singapore [url=http://cial1.xyz/cialis-professional.php]Cialis Professional[/url] Buy Now Isotretinoin Oratane
Propecia Flussig [url=http://antab1.xyz/antabuse-buy-online.php]Antabuse Buy Online[/url] Viagra Non Fa Male Clobetasol Medication Discount Shop With Free Shipping [url=http://buyac.xyz/accutane-online-buy.php]Accutane Online Buy[/url] Anuncios De Kamagra Generic Viagra Online Fast Shipping 112 [url=http://buyal.xyz/purchase-alli.php]Purchase Alli[/url] Real On Line Provera Order Germany Priligy Venta Espana [url=http://cial1.xyz/cialis-online-pharmacy.php]Cialis Online Pharmacy[/url] Kamagra How To Use Side Effects Of Amoxicillin In Dogs [url=http://amoxi.xyz/how-to-buy-amoxil.php]How To Buy Amoxil[/url] Propecia Prostate Cancer Prevention Keflex Dental Infection [url=http://buynolva.xyz/nolvadex-online.php]Nolvadex Online[/url] Pastillas Cialis Que Es Cephalexin Dose [url=http://viag1.xyz/viagra-prices.php]Viagra Prices[/url] Accutane 30mg Buy No Script Propecia Without A Otc [url=http://antabusa.xyz/buy-disulfiram.php]Buy Disulfiram[/url] Less Price To Buy Viagra